When a company contracts with the State or one of its instrumentalities, a dispute can raise a question ordinary commercial parties never face: can it be taken to a High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution?
The general rule
Courts have long held that purely contractual disputes, particularly those turning on disputed facts, belong before civil courts or arbitral tribunals. A writ court is not a forum for trying breaches of contract.
The exceptions
Yet the State does not shed its constitutional obligations when it signs a contract. Where its action is arbitrary, unfair or discriminatory, Article 14 remains engaged. In ABL International Ltd. v. Export Credit Guarantee Corporation of India (2004), the Supreme Court confirmed that a writ may lie even in contractual matters, including money claims, where the facts are not seriously disputed.
The State’s contracts are commercial, but its conduct is never purely private.
- Is the counterparty “State” under Article 12?
- Is the grievance about arbitrariness, or only about breach?
- Does an arbitration clause or other effective remedy exist?
This note is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice.



